November 15, 2013

Nutella Candy Bar Pie {Recipe!}

Today, I've got the perfect recipe for any leftover chocolate candy bars you might still have! I'm calling it Nutella Candy Bar Pie (creative, huh?)

Last week, I mentioned on Instagram that I had a TON of leftover candy. This year we didn't get a lot of tricker-treaters, so we didn't go through our bowl of chocolate. Instead, it's been sitting in our house, tempting us with it's chocolatey goodness. I decided to remedy that with this pie, that I took to our Bible study. It was a big hit!

Nutella Candy Bar Pie

(printable recipe here)

1/2 C. Nutella (plus 3 T. for topping)
8 oz Cream Cheese, softened
1 pkg (3.4 oz) Instant, Vanilla Pudding Mix
1 C. Cold Milk
10 Fun-Size Chocolate Candy Bars (I used Reeses Cups, Milky Way, Kit-Kat and Snickers), chopped

1-1/4 C. Graham Cracker Crumbs
3 T. Sugar
1/3 C. Butter, melted

Beat cream cheese with nutella, until combine. Add pudding mix and milk. Beat for 2 minutes. Set aside and make crust.

For crust: Mix graham cracker crumbs with sugar and butter until thoroughly combined. Pack mixture firmly into 9-inch pie pan and press into bottom and sides. Bake in a 350 degree oven for 8 minutes. Cool before filling with nutella mixture.

Top pie with diced candy bars. Melt remaining nutella and drizzle over candy bars with the prongs of a fork.

Refrigerate until firm, at least 4 hours.

Serve cold!

Honestly, this pie was so good! Rich and decadent? Absolutely! And, the mixture of candy bars made it a lot of fun to eat. Will this next  bite be peanut buttery or caramely...or both?! 

So, tell me, do YOU still have leftover candy at your house? If not, just go ahead and buy another bag and make this pie. You won't regret it! :)

Happy weekend!

Like what you see? Follow 52 Mantels!

52 Mantels
52 Mantels
52 Mantels
52 Mantels
52 Mantels

I link up here and here!


  1. Emily,

    I printed this to make tonight.
    I have a bag full of leftover candy and i want to get rid of it.
    but they're all the same kind because i ate all the good ones.
    this is actually just an excuse for me to go out and buy a jar of nutella!! :P


  2. We apperceive how admired it’s to omega replica advance central a section that looks absolutely just like the unique. This absolutely is why our via the internet abundance carries alone the a lot of breitling replica benign reproduction Porsche watches out there. Not even a able can be able to acquaint amid the different additional the carbon piece. We anticipate in acceptable the chump by hublot replica affairs pieces which ability be as intricate and finer engineered because the ample accomplishment affluence watches. Not just do we access as abutting for the 18-carat action as attainable, but we aswell absorb the common account Montres Omega Planet Ocean and circuitous designs because the cartier replica Porsche view.We accept the bigger banal online. Once you access a appearance from us we angle by that appearance and are blessed alone if you are satisfied. We accept one accurate from the best accomplishment rankings central the sector. Our prices are affirmed to be the everyman central the area and we will angle by rolex replica that pledge. Accord us a try and you will not be sorry. If acceptable accompany and co-workers see the appearance in your wrist you ability accept compliments. It’s up to you to acquaint that which you compensated for that view.

  3. Now, big price tag Replica handbags , to provide competition in more than one field.Mr. Frankel is is not affiliated with Replica watches UK, it was agreed that comment as an expert in the industry. Replica Watches unavailable for comment by the reporter of press time.Become a professional.In 2007, handbagreplica was the first luxury brand to participate in soccer. In 2011, the brand with the NBA team Miami Heat and the Los Angeles Lakers, was signed. Rolex Daytona This is a F1 race.


Ratings and Recommendations by outbrain